Apakah siswa Anda merasa lesu selama di kelas? Bisa jadi karena udara.

Sejak dimulainya pandemi, kualitas udara dalam ruangan atau  indoor air quality (IAQ) telah menjadi topik hangat di dunia pendidikan karena kualitas udara yang buruk di ruang kelas diketahui dapat mempercepat penyebaran penyakit yang ditularkan melalui udara di antara siswa. Namun di luar itu, banyak penelitian juga menunjukkan bagaimana IAQ dapat memengaruhi kinerja akademik.

IAQ, which is a blanket term referring to the air conditions in buildings,² is an important consideration for schools looking to improve their students' grades and lower their chronic absenteeism rate. According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), 1 out of 13 students suffer from chronic asthma,³ a leading cause of school absences.⁴ It's a respiratory condition that's aggravated by poor IAQ.

To prevent these problems, the EPA recommends schools to monitor and regulate different factors affecting IAQ, such as temperature and suspended particles, to name a few. Below, we'll briefly go over each of these factors and see their real impacts on student health and performance.

Slight changes in a classroom’s temperature may seem inconsequential, but studies have shown that even the smallest adjustments to indoor heating and cooling have notable effects on student scores.

Researchers from Harvard University and UCLA reviewing the effects of cumulative temperature on the scores of 10 million PSAT takers have noted that even a 1°F increase in heat in a warm learning environment is enough to drive learning performance down by 1%. And as the temperature rises, the scores get incrementally lower.⁵ These findings are consistent with other cases showing how high temperatures can impair a person’s motor skills and thinking.⁶

The same can be said for learning performance in cold environments. A separate case study in New South Wales reveals that a sharp drop in temperature—as a result of cold waves—lowers test scores by 1.2%. The researchers hypothesize that this change occurs because students are suddenly exposed to conditions that their bodies are not accustomed to.⁷

Much like temperature, indoor humidity also affects student performance. In a study conducted in 2021, a group of undergraduates were tasked to perform learning exercises in different rooms with varying levels of humidity. Researchers observed that if they deviated from the ideal relative humidity—which is 40%—and either lowered the room’s humidity to 20% or raised it to 60%, then the students would begin feeling uncomfortable and distracted. Compared to the experience of students in a room where the relative humidity was kept at 40%, their overall degree of distraction went down by 61.1%, their fatigue decreased by 23.3%, and reading speed by 12.2%.⁸

Although many may associate a faster reading speed with better student performance, it isn’t necessarily the case. Experts have noted how “speed reading” tends to affect accuracy and comprehension.⁹ The study results back this up. At 20% humidity, the students’ reading speed may have increased by a few words per minute, but their reading accuracy went down by 1.44%. At 60% humidity, their speed also went up, but their accuracy fell by 0.52%.¹⁰

Changes in humidity have also been linked to instances of asthma and asthma-like symptoms. A group of over 500 teachers participated in a study where they were exposed to low (< 30%) and high (> 60%) humidity classroom conditions. Many reported experiencing shortness of breath, wheezing, dry cough, and chest pains in either low or high humidity environments.¹¹

Another factor affecting IAQ in classrooms is carbon dioxide (CO₂), a very common gas that's a byproduct of our breathing and other natural processes. At low levels, it's safe to inhale, but once the amount surpasses certain thresholds, it begins affecting a student’s concentration and health.

A typical classroom would have a CO₂ level of around 400 to 1000 parts per million (ppm), depending on the room’s ventilation and crowdedness. A fully occupied room with inadequate ventilation traps CO₂ in the enclosed space and raises its level. Beyond 1000 ppm, students would start getting drowsy and experience other side effects like poor concentration, increased heart rate, and nausea.¹²

An experiment done in 2016 showed that in rooms where the CO₂ levels were increased, cognitive function scores went down significantly. For example, in rooms where the average CO₂ concentration was kept at 1400 ppm, the scores dropped by 50%. Activities like gathering and processing new information became more challenging. According to the researchers, on average, an increase of 400 ppm would already be enough to pull cognitive function scores down by at least 21%.¹³

As with CO₂, the same researchers found that high levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in the air also have negative effects on cognitive performance. They noted a 13% decrease in scores when the room’s total VOC (TVOC) concentration was upped by 500μg/m³.¹⁴

VOCs are gaseous compounds that are often found in construction materials, pesticides, and industrial cleaning products.¹⁵ Aside from its effects on student performance, exposure to VOCs is also known to cause eye, nose, and throat irritation, fatigue, dizziness and nausea, and in extreme cases, damages to internal organs like the liver, kidney, and the central nervous system.¹⁶

One of the most common VOCs is the highly toxic chemical called formaldehyde (CH₂O), which can be found in new carpeting and pressed wood furnishings such as chairs and particle boards.¹⁷ The United States Occupational Safety and Health Administration considers 100 ppm of CH₂O already dangerous as prolonged inhalation of it could lead to severe pulmonary reactions.¹⁸ In case there is a high level of CH₂O in a classroom, school staff should act quickly to ensure everyone’s safety.

The last of the common classroom pollutants is “particulate matter”, a term used to describe a mixture of tiny particles suspended in the air. They can be anything from dust, smoke, pollen, or other solid fragments or liquid droplets. Depending on their size, they’re classified as either PM₁₀ (< 10μm) or PM_2.5 (< 2.5μm). 

Between the two, health experts consider PM_2.5 the bigger health risk¹⁹ as it’s been known to infiltrate airways and bloodstreams causing a variety of symptoms like coughing, difficulty breathing, asthma, and irregular heartbeat.²⁰ Long-term inhalation of PM_2.5 can also lead to chronic bronchitis, cancer, and heart disease.²¹

Further research has also linked it to developmental problems in young children.²² Stanford University researchers tested the blood of kids exposed to wildfire smoke and found changes in a gene involved in the development and function of T cells, which are essential in preventing allergies and infections.²³

Because of PM_2.5’s size and density, it’s easy for the particles to travel far distances and enter classrooms, regardless of the school’s proximity to common sources like factories, open fields, or thoroughfare.²⁴ And for schools that still use chalkboards, both students and teachers are constantly exposed to high levels of PM_2.5 in the form of chalk dust. Researchers have noted that chalk use in classrooms with poor ventilation can increase indoor PM_2.5 concentration by almost 400%.²⁵ In an effort to regulate PM_2.5 levels in classrooms, schools have already begun investing in air filters and ionizers as part of their HVAC system upgrades.

The BenQ Board has built-in air quality sensors* that alert teachers via the widget when their classroom’s air quality is below satisfactory. Schools will have the option to customize their widget on the BenQ Board home screen and show only the readings that matter to them. Below is a quick guide explaining what each level means.

From the widget, they can easily see a summary of the real-time status of their classroom’s IAQ levels. In case any of them are high, teachers can immediately improve ventilation by simply opening a window or adjusting the HVAC settings of their classroom. If their BenQ Board is programmed to work with their school’s smart HVAC system, they don’t even need to lift a finger. The BenQ Board can send the live readings to the cloud, which the smart system can then process and use to immediately adjust the room’s air quality.

For more information on the BenQ Board air quality sensors, check out our related products below.